Mel Kiper on why he likes Justin Fields over Zach Wilson | The Max Kellerman Show

Mel Kiper Jr. joins Max Kellerman to discuss his Mock Draft 3.0, the New York Giants needs on offense and Zach Wilson vs. Justin Fields.
✔ Donate now to Jimmy V Fund here:
✔ Sign up for ESPN+:
✔ Get the ESPN App:
✔ Subscribe to ESPN on ALnick:
✔ Subscribe to ESPN FC on ALnick:
✔ Subscribe to NBA on ESPN on ALnick:
✔ Watch ESPN on ALnick TV:
ESPN on Social Media:
► Follow on Twitter: espn
► Like on Facebook: espn
► Follow on Instagram: espn
Visit ESPN on ALnick to get up-to-the-minute sports news coverage, scores, highlights and commentary for NFL, NHL, MLB, NBA, College Football, NCAA Basketball, soccer and more.
More on




  • Mel saying Fields > Zac is a given that Zac is going to be a legend and Fields is going to be a bust

    Fredo SadtanaFredo Sadtana6 ditë më parë
  • Yeah, but could Fields put up big numbers against the very tough teams Zach Wilson faced in 2020, like Navy, Western Kentucky, Texas State, and NORTHERN Alabama? (this is sarcasm for those who missed it).

    pantherman16pantherman166 ditë më parë
  • People who like Fields do not like him for any reason other than his success at tOSU. He's not a better passer than Wilson at all and that's what it comes down to. He's faster and bigger but we aint comparing linebackers.

    Heath HendersonHeath Henderson6 ditë më parë
  • Can't be the only one thinking he's hedging his bets here.

    fwd105fwd1059 ditë më parë
  • Zach Wilson, will be eaten alive in the NFL. He played at BYU. That says it all.

    SHOPQEYSSHOPQEYS13 ditë më parë
  • People can stop with this Mac Jones to the Niners at #3 nonsense. The 49ers will draft Justin Fields.

    bhongtasticbhongtastic13 ditë më parë
  • Let me guess, he will be wrong but not admit it.. 3 yrs from now blame o line for fields failures

    DGGDGG14 ditë më parë
  • Imagine if fields goes to lions

    Stanley EzenStanley Ezen14 ditë më parë
  • This might be the first time I have ever agreed with Mel Kiper Jr.

    Jendiye MaeligaJendiye Maeliga14 ditë më parë
  • Wilson was ranked 18th in the nation in 2019 when playing against more competitive teams in the PAC.

    Ira HorwitzIra Horwitz15 ditë më parë
  • Mel and Todd Mcshay both big time racist who dont like black Qbs

    Rod smithRod smith16 ditë më parë
  • Kiper also said Sam Darnold is a franchise QB.

    john jacksonjohn jackson16 ditë më parë
  • Have a great day god love you .

    ElieElie17 ditë më parë
  • Fields is #2 but I hope he slips cuz I don’t want him goin to the jets🤢

    mac ferrismac ferris17 ditë më parë
  • For everybody loving on Fields, I just want to point out Mel Kiper had Watson as a second rounder talent a few years ago with Trubisky as the best QB of the class. Fields cannot read defenses or is slow to do so. Fields lacks the mental part of the game and few develop it.

    MartiMarti17 ditë më parë
    • Lacks the mental part? Ignorant comment. 3.9 GPA. He did extremely well in the Ohio State offensive system which is different than the offensive systems in the SEC which are pro orientated. He will need 1 season to adjust. His raw talent gives him a higher ceiling. Head to head he has had better games than Trevor Lawrence since high school. One season behind Garafalo in San Francisco with tutelage from Shanahan’s offensive staff and he will be able to compete in the NFL at an elite level.

      Ira HorwitzIra Horwitz15 ditë më parë
  • I have a better chance of winning the lotto than Mel Kiper making a good prediction.

    kifley19kifley1917 ditë më parë
  • Brady - worst athlete out of 32 QB's every season. Jackson - best athlete out of 32 QB's Brady - 10 super bowls. Jackson - 0 conf champ games (so far of course but on a great team..) Give me a great QB over a great "athlete" any day...

    Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
  • funny to see all the "experts" comments on here - as a massive NFL fan from the UK the best evaluator of QB's that I see out there based on results is Chris Simms - and he has Zach as no. 1 and Fields no. 5 - therefore, I fully expect Zach will be a bigger success - although of course this is partly dependent on where they land... So if the above comes true, is Mel Kiper going to finally resign his job for repeatedly getting his "expert" analysis wrong on an industrial scale...?? I doubt it lol...

    Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
  • Northwestern and Indiana would have crushed BYU . Zack couldn't even handle Coastal Carolina on primetime. That dud of a game should have put him as a top 5-10 QB candidate

    Let There B Light TVLet There B Light TV17 ditë më parë
  • Just take what kipper says and do the opposite

    BillionDollarBiscuitBillionDollarBiscuit17 ditë më parë
  • Watch Fields end up having the best career out of all these QBs..

    Breaking ReactionsBreaking Reactions17 ditë më parë
    • @987 123 get a life

      Breaking ReactionsBreaking Reactions15 ditë më parë
    • @Breaking Reactions his mom works my street corner

      987 123987 12315 ditë më parë
    • @Russ Coates your mom won't

      Breaking ReactionsBreaking Reactions16 ditë më parë
    • he wont

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
  • Justin fields has such a long wind up passing motion. Corners will be picking him off for years. Hard pass on Fields.

    Learner OfTruthLearner OfTruth18 ditë më parë
  • I don’t see why anyone cares with Mel Kiper says...This is the same dude who said Julio can’t catch, and JaMarcus was going to be the best quarterback of his generation....Just because you’ve been doing some thing the longest doesn’t mean you any good at it. No one can argue that in the past four years Chris Sims has hit on almost every single draft at double the rate Mel Kiper has. The draft is all about storyline. Chris Simmons comes into it with an open mind and doesn’t pay attention to the storylines. He said Tua was not gonna be able to hang with Justin Herbert. He said Mahomes was the best quarterback in the draft followed closely by Deshaun Watson. He said Lamar Jackson was incredible. These were all considered heresy to the so-called experts. I he would’ve picked Justin Jefferson and maple Tron over Jerry Judy which turned out to be 100% right. Mel Kuiper Mrs. 50% of the draft. Why does anyone listen to these guys. If you don’t have an athletic background in football specifically. And you don’t break down film to explain exactly why you love a guy, I really don’t wanna hear it

    Chad MesiChad Mesi18 ditë më parë
  • I dont see how anybody could think Wilson is better than Fields, after Fields ran 4.4 at his Pro day. He's bigger , faster and tougher than Wilson. He played in the big games while Wilson padded his stats against junior college teams . He fits the Jets needs better and Wilson will work better in SF with a year behind Jimmy G. Wilson is to slightly built to stand up to the punishment playing for the Jets, in the NFL. I hope for both guys that Fields goes #2 to the Jets.

    john wonderjohn wonder18 ditë më parë
  • "49ers at 12"? Keep up!

    Danny KrinkleDanny Krinkle18 ditë më parë
  • I'm fine, like beyond FINE with Fields not going to the Jets.

    LaBountiLaBounti18 ditë më parë
    • On god

      Sean OliverSean Oliver11 ditë më parë
  • Justin Fields lmao, out of the league in 5yrs

    KryptKrypt18 ditë më parë
  • Kiper is wrong the majority of the time. How does this clown still have a job? 🤡

    Jason TaylorJason Taylor18 ditë më parë
  • these incompetent gms are about to make the same mistake that they made when the Bears took Trubisky over Watson & Mahomes because there isn't a measurable or intangible that would show that Wilson is a better QB than Justin Fields

    nate greennate green18 ditë më parë
    • yet wilson shows the most similar traits to mahomes and watson... hmmmm :)

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
  • It is funny how black athletes always have to be 10 times better than white athletes. Mitch Tribiski drafted before Watson of Mahomes. Kiper was wrong then and continues to pick white QBs over black players. Now Zach Wilson who lost to Coastal Carolina is better than Fields who beat much better teams and has only 2 losses in 2 seasons? It is the same everywhere you go. I seen a black kid that leads his highschool jV in every stat hitting and pitching and is the fastest player. Yet he does not move up to varsity and players who have not hit the ball out of the infield move up. People are so biased it makes no sense.

    Ashamed AmericanAshamed American18 ditë më parë
  • mel keiper is growing as an analyst, is he sheddding his racist tendencies. chriss simms is picking them up

    Emeka EmezieEmeka Emezie18 ditë më parë
  • I wouldn't select fields cause of that chin patch

    Joseph DingleberryJoseph Dingleberry19 ditë më parë
  • Wait, so Mel talking about Wilson but bringing old conversations to the new conversations? He said in 2019 Wilson was a 5th round pick and Fields was better.. can someone tell me that you got to critique a guys game that just happened... not in 2019, that just means Fields regressed if you ask me

    Sokhan ChhunSokhan Chhun19 ditë më parë
  • Mel Kiper i will retire if that last person I’d ever listen too

    CBACBA19 ditë më parë
  • Like him going to the panthers, perfect fit!!

    Hot FireHot Fire19 ditë më parë

    EM SrEM Sr19 ditë më parë
  • Mel is spitting rn. I understand the Wilson hype but like mel said you just cant forget about 2019 in a full season where he was just balling every single game and zach looked like an avg qb against inferior competition

    Ypc.XavierYpc.Xavier19 ditë më parë
    • @Ypc.Xavier i agree and I hope he does but the AFC is getting stacked with great QB's - mahomes, herbert, burrow, wilson/ lawrence (maybe), allen, watson (maybe) along with good QB's/teams Cleveland, Indy, Tennesee and of course Belichick - so I fear Lamar will never make it to the super bowl.. NFC is the place to be at the mo - if Watson does get through his issues I would recommend him to go to the NFC - Brady cant last forever!!

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
    • @Russ Coates I get where your coming from but Brees didn’t win a SB till he was 30, Aaron Rodgers got his at 27, Peyton at 30, Marino never got one. Lamar is 24 it’s ok he hasn’t seen great success yet

      Ypc.XavierYpc.Xavier17 ditë më parë
    • @Ypc.Xavier and zero conf champ games so far on a great team - history shows great athletes can win regular season games (lamar, cunningham, vick), but great QB's win Super Bowls - Brady, Manning, Mahomes, Roethlesberger, Brees, Wilson, Rodgers.. Of course it could change in the future but the NFL is very much a passing league at the moment so give me the great QB over the great athlete to win tough playoff games against tough defenses..

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
    • @Russ Coates yeah and Lamar went 32nd because he was a “poor mans Cam Newton with less size” Wins Mvp and 12 games per yr🤷🏾‍♂️

      Ypc.XavierYpc.Xavier17 ditë më parë
    • players develop and evolve at that age - rapidly - wilson is a different animal now - with a far better "NFL" skillset - fields is a poor mans Lamar...

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
  • Zach Wilson is a Carson Wentz player. Fields is better.

    Musein MohammedMusein Mohammed19 ditë më parë
  • FIELDS best option after Lawrence or almost better.....look .....just look at his college stats....9.5+ yds per pass....40-50 rushes per year...avg 400+ yds....with 4-5 rush TDs each year as well.....Omg....this guy is like Kyler Murray+WATSON..... Annnnnnnd THROWING TO RED RED RED SHIRTS.....IS A SECRET BENEFIT..... ITS BASED ON MUSCLE MEMORY....HE IS USED TO THROWING TO RED JERSEYS....OR WHITE AND RED.....BUT FIELDS IS USE TO THROWING TO RED JERSEYS IN A TOUGHER DIVISION.....AND FIELDS PLAY AGAINST TOUGHER PLAYERS.......FIELDS IS SMARTER.....RUNNER UP TO HEISMAN..... FIELDS ACCURACY IS GREAT......... THINK ABOUT WASHINGTON USING MAROON COLOR JERSEY'S...... LOOK AT WASHINGTON RECORD WITH TJOSE SAME COLOURED BALL JERSEYS......

    ChristianChristian19 ditë më parë
  • How much college football do you have to watch in order to be a draft analysis?

    Bar WillBar Will19 ditë më parë
    • I guess at least 100 games

      Basiru JabbiBasiru Jabbi18 ditë më parë
  • Niners suck anyways. Terrible fans

    Tony AngeloTony Angelo19 ditë më parë
  • Even if the Jets don’t draft Wilson at 2 I hope my 9ers take Fields at 3.

    Stevie P23Stevie P2320 ditë më parë
    • So does Seattle and Arizona and LA. Lololololololol

      Wally WankerWally Wanker18 ditë më parë
  • If he slides, I'd love to see him in Carolina with DJ Moore, Robby Anderson, and of course C-Mac.

    RicoSuaVeRicoSuaVe20 ditë më parë
    • Y’all got Sam darnold

      Chris PerezChris Perez11 ditë më parë
  • I believe the niners are in love with more then 1 of these qb for us to trade so much for this 3rd pick

    Mistah 600Mistah 60020 ditë më parë
  • The New York football Giants are one beast off the edge like parsons. Kwity Paye azeez away from being the scariest defense In Football They coming big time 🔥🔥

    Tsvi MizrahiTsvi Mizrahi20 ditë më parë
  • What sucks is Fields is going to be better than Jimmy on the 9ers and everyone's gonna say the Jets shudda drafted him instead of Wilson which is stupid

    T DT D20 ditë më parë
  • Mel it’s like comparing Akli smith vs Aaron Rodgers! You are wrong Mel

    TN gamerTN gamer20 ditë më parë
    • You’re only saying that because Fields is black lmao

      Jarred RiceJarred Rice19 ditë më parë
  • Can anyone give me 1 example WHY kellerman is relevant???

    haaiitiihaaiitii20 ditë më parë
    • He’s just as football knowledgeable as stephene A smith Clueless

      Tsvi MizrahiTsvi Mizrahi20 ditë më parë
  • Chris Simms>Mel Kiper

    Joseph RoblesJoseph Robles20 ditë më parë
  • There is no room for another Wilson in the NFL at QB, Fields is a refresh name and sound he's going to dominate a football field.

    reptilexcq2reptilexcq220 ditë më parë
  • Kiper is clueless. He is a comedy act.

    James ReynoldsJames Reynolds20 ditë më parë
  • Zach Wilson is a great qb but we have more film of fields having great games and throws plus he is duel threat

    Dictator BruhDictator Bruh20 ditë më parë
  • How does mel have this job😕

    Matt MoranoMatt Morano20 ditë më parë
  • Fields gonna go to the niners

    C JayC Jay20 ditë më parë
  • Mel Kiper always has bold takes

    ReckHouseCOReckHouseCO20 ditë më parë
  • Jets need a playmaker for Sam not a QB

    ted stoneted stone20 ditë më parë
  • I'm happy for fields, hes going to end up in better situation than Lawrence and Wilson

    AAronAAron20 ditë më parë
    • @Yung Magneno way better ? He’s a way better athlete I will give him that but the nfl is littered with great athletes that couldn’t produce . So many qbs have the physical tools but not the mental makeup . Brady looked like the kid working at your local burger joint coming out. But he is the best to ever play the game. What about manning ? I could out run him. Fields needs the most work in the mental area that’s the problem with Ohio qbs.

      Wally WankerWally Wanker13 ditë më parë
    • @Wally Wanker way better than haskins watch this

      Yung MagnenoYung Magneno13 ditë më parë
    • Sure he will , going to what ? The Washington football team lmfao. No one is taking baby Haskins high.

      Wally WankerWally Wanker18 ditë më parë
  • People forget that Northwestern had a top 10 defense and Indiana was REALLY good. I want the 9ers to take Fields

    Will McCoyWill McCoy20 ditë më parë
    • NW D was #1. IU D was #5. So yeah, you right.

      987 123987 12315 ditë më parë
    • Your right. Ppl are quick to overlook all of the bad games wilson had these last two years but will jump out at the 3-4 sub par games justin had over the same span. Im sure Shananhan can help coach Jfields outta the issue with his decision making.

      Ypc.XavierYpc.Xavier19 ditë më parë
    • he still ran for 200 yards and 2 touchdowns even if he was getting blitzed the whole game fields to the bay is the way

      Israel RamirezIsrael Ramirez19 ditë më parë
  • Hey Max screw you the Giants have been pretty bad as well lol

    Petey RosePetey Rose20 ditë më parë
  • Mac Jones is better than both Fields and Lance. Zach Wilson is the best QB in this draft and it’s not close.

    Pablo CastilloPablo Castillo20 ditë më parë
    • Agreed. I Played qb 17 yrs and I Coach now Max jones is most nfl ready now. Perfect for ne. Belichick type of qb

      Tsvi MizrahiTsvi Mizrahi20 ditë më parë
  • Mel Kiper is wrong most of the time, don't know why he still got a job...

    Y MY M21 ditë më parë
    • Agree with this comment, but I also agree with Mel Kiper for the first time

      Jendiye MaeligaJendiye Maeliga14 ditë më parë
    • hes like the weather men! well UK weather men

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
    • Because his hair is amazing

      Casey James MusicCasey James Music17 ditë më parë
  • I think the niners want Wilson but are willing to settle for Fields. If wilson is there tho you cant pass up that arm.

    jebusm86jebusm8621 ditë më parë
    • Wilson way not better than Fields

      987 123987 12315 ditë më parë
    • Other way around

      potential stevepotential steve19 ditë më parë
  • PAYE is gonna have to wear BIGGER SHOULDER PADS in the NFL and he might get stood up easier than college . Other than that I like PAYE as the best pass rusher in the draft😉

    Big Daddy NateBig Daddy Nate21 ditë më parë
  • As an Ohio State and Fields fan, I want him to go #3 to the niners. If that happens the path will be paved for him to be a success

    Carlo FilippiniCarlo Filippini21 ditë më parë
    • @Moses Valle threat? Sign him, and start him. You’ll win the super bowl

      John WillisJohn Willis5 ditë më parë
    • @Shane Fuoco Brady seems to prove game manager makes you a game changer. Jimmy G just can't fully manage a game

      Danny's VlogsDanny's Vlogs12 ditë më parë
    • Ohio state QBs are bust in the nfl though

      Night OwlNight Owl13 ditë më parë
    • @KING Dxvid Wow, brilliant?! Yes Lance played in a "nobody division" and his teammates were "NOBODIES" Can you think deep enough to figure out how that works? (Hint: it puts him on a level playing field w/Jones, Fields, and every other qb!)!

      Escaped AwayEscaped Away15 ditë më parë
    • @jayman10 he coming baby

      987 123987 12315 ditë më parë
  • Fields Reminds me Of Cam Newton SF I like it

    L.O.V.EL.O.V.E21 ditë më parë
  • Let this sink in fields has played 4 defensive players that are projected to go in the first round this year!! Northwestern and Indiana were top 15 defensives in college football with elite secondary play!! Plus it felt like ohio state was in covid protocol the whole season he had really no time to gel with his starters that stuff is really forgot in all this hate for fields!!

    Trent McQuarrieTrent McQuarrie21 ditë më parë
    • lol be great to read yours and bigdaps comments when Zach is flying high and justin is just another average running QB... :)

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
    • Dude it’s cool...we know what Fields has done...Historically great performances against historically great and elite teams...ask these f@ckers to explain in plain English what has Zach Wilson done and against who...and you won’t hear a mumbling word!! 😂🤣 Zach Wilson ain’t sh@t!👎🏾

      bigdap100bigdap10021 ditë më parë
  • Mel spoke truth on Wilson compared to Fields.

    Brandon PottsBrandon Potts21 ditë më parë
  • R u kidding how many Ohio st. QB still play in the nfl?????

    Taion LoTaion Lo21 ditë më parë
    • That makes no since they are different people abd they were coached by urban myers justin wasnt dude just likr the people that said oregan qbs arent good in the nfl look at justin Herbert

      Amos: dee Amos:deesherman1600Amos: dee Amos:deesherman160021 ditë më parë
  • Most of the best young qb played. 4 small school. !!

    sir dick ellissir dick ellis21 ditë më parë
    • Exactly! These QBs coming from big schools have an easy life with top players. Of course they will put up big numbers. It's a given. But yet when they go to the league they struggle. Then out of no where the no name players are the ones who shine. I'm rocking with Zach Wilson.

      Carbon CampaignCarbon Campaign21 ditë më parë
  • When has a Ohio state qb been good in the nfl

    Smokey The goatSmokey The goat21 ditë më parë
    • @erik puka no it doesn’t

      PLUG CAPPLUG CAP21 ditë më parë
    • @PLUG CAP it has everything to do with him

      erik pukaerik puka21 ditë më parë
    • They have nothing to do with Justin

      PLUG CAPPLUG CAP21 ditë më parë
    • Exactly! They go to the league thinking they will have the same talent as college then get a rude awakening

      Carbon CampaignCarbon Campaign21 ditë më parë
  • Whichever one out of Wilson or Fields that Lands with the 49ers will be the big winner.

    retributionpicsretributionpics21 ditë më parë
  • I could’ve sworn Mel was shitting on fields like 2 months ago

    VinoVino21 ditë më parë
  • Whatever Mel suggests you go the other way... I'll take Sims opinion over Mel's..

    jeremy guthriejeremy guthrie21 ditë më parë
  • Who was better than Justin Fields last year??? It was a non-COVID year, when everyone played on an even playing one was better than Fields, Joe Burrow maybe and that’s it. Now we’re acting like Fields is chopped liver b/c the guy had to take the little time and preparation he had to pull the frikkin team out of a disastrous situation??? That’s BS! Fields is better now than ever and he is the real QB1.

    bigdap100bigdap10021 ditë më parë
  • Zack Wilson gonna be a underdog

    Zay 900Zay 90021 ditë më parë
    • @Pure chaos I can agree with that lol

      Zay 900Zay 90017 ditë më parë
    • Knowing the history of the nfl draft the best qb from this draft will either be a late first rounder or 3 or later.

      Pure chaosPure chaos17 ditë më parë
    • He’s gonna be the #2 pick in the draft bruh, how is that being a underdog??

      Robert SchmahlRobert Schmahl18 ditë më parë
  • mel kiper is the biggest con artist out there

    NPCNPC21 ditë më parë
  • Mel Kiper is an awful qb evaluator.

    notsodelusionalnotsodelusional22 ditë më parë
  • So we going to act like Mel wasn’t saying the exact opposite not too long ago

    Keaton Miller-TrentKeaton Miller-Trent22 ditë më parë
    • @The NDstructible1 i just read your nonsense and realized i'll never get that 20 seconds of my life back. Thx bud.

      987 123987 12315 ditë më parë
    • Can't trust any of these media guys

      987 123987 12315 ditë më parë
    • @The NDstructible1 I wonder where you got this opinion from since for the last like 30 years of the NFL, GM’s have valued the QB position very high and if there is a quality franchise guy you have to have him. But if you say it’s wrong I guess it must be right. It’s not even like this draft has a Bosa or Chase young type talent to draft that high, this is ridiculous.

      Jahved ColeJahved Cole18 ditë më parë
    • @The NDstructible1 mond...have you actually watched multiple a&m games? he is so inconsistent and has horrible mechanics. turn off the chris simms man. mond stinks, there’s a reason he’s gonna be a day 2 or 3 qb. lance also was the one who made the reads on his team, not only did he make reads in the passing plays, he also set up all of his own protections pre snap, himself. you aren’t giving accurate facts man. so tell me this, was mahomes a bad pick? rodgers a bad pick? how about josh allen? watson wasn’t ready either according to some analysts. lamar jackson? how about herbert, he was expected to be a project but showed ready before anyone expected, was he a bad pick? these are just some guys who are in the nfl who by your criteria should’ve all gone in the 2nd or 3rd round or to a team with an old qb. thats not how the nfl works, you draft for your needs and since qb is the most important position you draft that need early, even if it is a project.

      Jahved ColeJahved Cole19 ditë më parë
    • @Jahved Cole and that is why your team will also suck another year. Again fine picking up QB late first if you are GB or Tampa with aging QBs for the future. Top 10 are on field picks or you literally get nothing from that pick. Means you will not improve. Picking QB cause at this point every team should take QBs till none are left then. I love the NFL but too much focus is being put of QB. Draft HOF over a future starting QB.

      The NDstructible1The NDstructible119 ditë më parë
  • Mel Kiper has no credibility anymore how does ESPN+ sponsor his Mock Drafts smh

    G Propho LoadingG Propho Loading22 ditë më parë
  • A couple of months ago, Mel was saying the exact opposite.

    Junior QuarlesJunior Quarles22 ditë më parë
    • Mel Kiper is useless I can't believe he's still in his job over the pond !

      Russ CoatesRuss Coates17 ditë më parë
    • @erik puka no

      Kevin2001Kevin200119 ditë më parë
    • A person is allowed to change his opinion

      erik pukaerik puka21 ditë më parë
    • Thank you. I thought I was tripping.

      Kisembe NamusyuleKisembe Namusyule21 ditë më parë
  • Fields is fools gold! I don’t see him being durable in the nfl. No shade but his legs don’t seem sturdy to me, I can see them being the first to go. If I’m fields better hope and pray he gets drafted to the right team and system could easily end up like Pryor Barrett, Miller and or Haskins. The nfl makes college stars into busts very fast 😂

    Will ParkerWill Parker22 ditë më parë
  • Niners going after Wilson or Fields

    Swish DavidSwish David22 ditë më parë
  • With all due respect for Zach Wilson I gotta give Justin fields credit he played real competition yall forgetting how good he was last year he almost took them to the national championship if it wasn't for the refs but it is what it is,and his 2020 season didn't start until late October and he beat Clemson this year, yes he does have flaws but every qb has flaws

    FanetøFanetø22 ditë më parë
    • @K Swag lmfao Wilson lost to coastal Carolina

      Malik WilliamsMalik Williams20 ditë më parë
    • @K Swag he had an o line of 26 y/o true freshman

      ReenyReeny20 ditë më parë
    • Real competition? Lol, that's the dumbest argument ever, do you think Wilson's teamates were as good? 😂

      K SwagK Swag20 ditë më parë
    • @Y M Haskins couldn’t even make the cfp in starting only 1 season to fields’ 2 seasons as a starter taking his team to what should’ve been 2 nattys... ring a bell?

      ReenyReeny20 ditë më parë
    • @Y M just watch, I'll leave it at that

      AAronAAron20 ditë më parë
  • Finally someone said what I've been saying. I'll go a step further. Wilson is nothing but a flash in the pan who happened to play no competition. Look at the 1 sec team he played last er in tennessee. Go back nd look at that game. Jets need to draft fields. Then again, they are the jets for reason. Theyll ignore red flags like wilson injury history, draft him anyway nd wilson will be injury plagued his entire career while fields goes to the 49ers nd dominates

    R ThompsonR Thompson22 ditë më parë
  • Y'all like to hype the white qb now they say Mac jones is better smh can the madness stop

    will irvwill irv22 ditë më parë
    • @erik puka yeah he has a kirk cousins comparison

      FanetøFanetø21 ditë më parë
    • @Fanetø Kirk Cousins has the 3rd highest Completion percentage in NFL history.He is a pretty good QB.

      erik pukaerik puka21 ditë më parë
    • Facts Mac Jones plays like kirk cousins at best

      FanetøFanetø22 ditë më parë
  • Nope Zach is clearly better

    KingJordanKingJordan22 ditë më parë
  • Oh yes San Francisco 49ers

    Francis LumanogFrancis Lumanog22 ditë më parë
  • Confirmed: Fields will be a bust & Wilson will be a of Mel Kiper’s draft analysis...always go opposite of what this guy thinks.

    KOTJ412KOTJ41222 ditë më parë
  • People are way over thinking this to the point where Fields is trending to be picked after Wilson. Fields is better and always has been, period. It is pretty clear. There is always a prospect or two whose stock drops between the season and the draft because people are just sitting around thinking about it too much. Fields is that guy this year.

    Steven WilliamsSteven Williams22 ditë më parë
    • @Brandon Griswold Fields played against better competition but also played with better weapons. It goes both ways, put Zach on a team as decked as ohio state and it's another story

      Isaac DIsaac D16 ditë më parë
    • @Lincoln MacEachern You know who else played no competition? Josh Allen. So your argument is invalid.

      Prestige ShogunPrestige Shogun16 ditë më parë
    • @Prestige Shogun Who played against third rate defenders? Wilson.

      Lincoln MacEachernLincoln MacEachern17 ditë më parë
    • @Shane ! Ohio state wasn’t even allowed to play in the big ten championship and two days before that they said they could play so I don’t wanna hear that argument. And Running in On the goal line and in the red zone doesn’t make you mobile. Justin Fields has more carries because he’s a running quarterback and Ohio state wanted to use his strengths. Justin was running from his own 30 yard line to the opponents 45 yard line everywhere. Unlike Zach Wilson Running 10 Touchdowns against trash defenses Like Utsa, LA Tech, Troy, Etc. Look at who he’s playing. Justin Could have had way better numbers if Zach And Justin switched teams and all you Zach Wilson followers would be sayin the same thing. “LOOK AT HIS SCHEDULE”. And It has everything to do with Justin being black. There’s always one white quarterback that’s better than the rest. Tribusky, Manziel, Lock, Herbert is good I’ll give them that. But still Before the Clemson game it was Justin and Trevor Now you got Zach Wilson out of nowhere just because of the numbers he put up on trash defenses. When Zach Wilson is a bust. Hate to say I told you so

      JuJuOnDat CrazeJuJuOnDat Craze17 ditë më parë
    • @Shane ! With Carson Wentz padding their stats big time 🤣🤣

      Brandon GriswoldBrandon Griswold17 ditë më parë
  • Justin Fields really is a better athlete, passer, and has better speed. Wilson very well might do better in the NFL but honestly, how many QBs have went on to have illustrious careers that Kiper was high on?

    Winford T. McGuillacuttyWinford T. McGuillacutty22 ditë më parë
    • @Prestige Shogun yes because fields played less games

      Eli EliEli Eli21 ditë më parë
    • @Eli Eli You do realize Wilson had better stats than fields this year...right?

      Prestige ShogunPrestige Shogun21 ditë më parë
    • @Prestige Shogun yes he is, in the beginning of the year he had crazy stats like 6 incompletions not ints and like 6 tds in his first three games and his performance against Clemson was excellent

      Eli EliEli Eli21 ditë më parë
    • Fields is DEFINITELY NOT a better passer than Wilson. Not even close.

      Prestige ShogunPrestige Shogun21 ditë më parë
  • sorry mel but ur rap sheet of getting qbs wrong is just too long for me to take your qb projections seriously

    Dave SmithDave Smith22 ditë më parë
  • Justin fields college football stats are way better than Zach Wilson statistics and college football at BYU

    Leroy FisherLeroy Fisher22 ditë më parë
    • So what? He played on a stacked team.

      Carbon CampaignCarbon Campaign21 ditë më parë
    • Who was better than Justin Fields last year??? It was a non-COVID year, when everyone played on an even playing one was better than Fields, Joe Burrow maybe and that’s it. Now we’re acting like Fields is chopped liver b/c the guy had to take the little time and preparation he had to pull the frikkin team out of a disastrous situation??? That’s BS! Fields is better now than ever and he is the real QB1.

      bigdap100bigdap10021 ditë më parë
    • @gnielsen07 they also had better talent around them. And fields is much more of a hard worker and alpha dog. He’s also more athletic and has better throwing mechanics and makes better reads then both of them.

      Brandon BankheadBrandon Bankhead21 ditë më parë
    • Tim Tebow & Johnny manziel had better stats than both. How’d that work out?

      gnielsen07gnielsen0722 ditë më parë
  • Top 3 picks are all qbs maybe even 4

    Steven ZouSteven Zou22 ditë më parë
  • All these fools 3 months ago said zack over fields lmao clowns

    eric cuevaseric cuevas22 ditë më parë
    • @Jay Savage what? Zach Wilson literally has the strongest arm in college.....

      Prestige ShogunPrestige Shogun21 ditë më parë
    • They saw Zach Wilson pro day dude Got a weak arm all his plays were dink and dunk plays.

      Jay SavageJay Savage22 ditë më parë
  • I have a feeling 49ers are taking Fields with the #3 now. IMO not a good idea

    dabig 25dabig 2522 ditë më parë
    • @Isaiah Pinal exactly kyle know what fields can do because he trained him i think that's the pick at three it fields or trade-up again for fields

      Ninersallday 55Ninersallday 5522 ditë më parë
    • For the niners it is good but for the rest of the teams it’s not

      Isaiah PinalIsaiah Pinal22 ditë më parë
  • Of all the bigtime Ohio State quarterbacks in recent years name one that's done well in the NFL... I'll wait

    Mike ChapmanMike Chapman22 ditë më parë
    • @Mike Chapman none of those QBs were expected to be NFL studs besides Haskins and the book is still out on him. His problem is maturity not lack of talent. All the other QBs you listed were undrafted or mid to late round picks. Idk why people act like Ohio State has had multiple 1st round QB busts. On top of all of that, they don't even run the same offense that they did with Barrett, Braxton, Pryor and Cardale. Those were Urban Meyer/Jim Tressel QBs. Ryan Day actually recruits QBs who don't run read option exclusively and can throw downfield.

      NicholpickleNicholpickle20 ditë më parë
    • @Leroy-Will Jones don't disrespect Mahomes like that

      erik pukaerik puka21 ditë më parë
    • @Jackyc1234 Clark 👍

      Ninersallday 55Ninersallday 5521 ditë më parë
    • Each player is unique . Isn't nearly as important where they come from , as where they land . The coaches have biases , good team , lousy team , schemes , coaching changes , locker room chemistry etc .. .

      Jackyc1234 ClarkJackyc1234 Clark21 ditë më parë
    • Cam Newton went to auburn not many great QB come from auburn

      Bigger man DanBigger man Dan21 ditë më parë
  • I honestly think Lawrence . Fields . Lance & Wilson will be studs an pro Bowlers . Can’t go wrong

    Shad RondellShad Rondell22 ditë më parë
    • Not up to them, talent around u matters

      Mo VoMo Vo22 ditë më parë
  • Zack Wilson is another Mahomes, with better footwork!!

    Robert SchmahlRobert Schmahl22 ditë më parë
    • He's a mix of mahomes and herbert

      FanetøFanetø22 ditë më parë
  • Niners will take a qb at 3 now

    1974chevrolet C101974chevrolet C1022 ditë më parë
    • Well if the Niners take Justin Fields at 3 I think that will be a worthy pick but if Lynch and Shanny decide to throw away the future for Mac Jones, they need to be fired on the spot

      Daniel AndreDaniel Andre14 ditë më parë
    • Probably Trey Lance

      Patrick PerduePatrick Perdue20 ditë më parë
    • Niners need to take a coach at 3

      Absolute GamingAbsolute Gaming20 ditë më parë
    • 😂😂😂😂 I thought they gave up 3 firsts and a third for a different position 😂😂😂😂😂

      K SwagK Swag20 ditë më parë
    • They are absolutely taking a QB. It makes no sense to move up to take anything else but that.

      Zeeshon KhanZeeshon Khan21 ditë më parë
  • I can't stand the argument of who did Wilson play compared to fields? OK I get that but tell me where that's mattered when it comes to success in the NFL. Big Ben - Miami of Ohio Flacco - Delaware Romo and Garappalo - Eastern Illinois Wentz - North Dakota Kurt Warner - northern Iowa Steve McNair - Alcorn st Brett Favre - southern Mississippi Josh Allen - Wyoming etc... you get the point it doesn't matter plus BYU is a solid program who's had just as much success or more putting out professional QBs than Ohio st

    Dylan GiffordDylan Gifford22 ditë më parë
    • @Caleb Skinner the point is it’s not about schools. Because there is a number of bums from big schools. Haskins, Darnold, Barrett, Kizer, Bisky, Ponder, let downs like mariotta and Winston. They played “big stage against competition” who cares what can you do on Sunday is what matters

      niles tniles t20 ditë më parë
    • Theres an equal or greater number of people that played at Power 5 schools: Brady, Breeze, Rogers, Wilson, Watson, Mahomes, Jackson, Cousins, Burrow, Tua, Herbert, Ryan, Stafford, Tannehiil. And the list goes to older QBs: Manning, Manning, Montana, Moon, Elway, Aikman. We romanticize the small schools wins so much that we forget some real history.

      Caleb SkinnerCaleb Skinner20 ditë më parë
    • Thank you

      Jarvis JuiceJarvis Juice21 ditë më parë
    • There a difference them dude dominated every year in college unlike zach Wilson

      Jay SavageJay Savage22 ditë më parë
    • This is not a great point way more Big school QBs in the league with success Zach had a bad 2019

      Mr HatMr Hat22 ditë më parë